Currently the UFC has 8 members of their Hall of Fame which include: Royce Gracie,
Chuck Liddell, Ken Shamrock, Dan Severn, Mark Coleman, Randy Couture, Matt Hughes and Charles “Mask” Lewis. Each of those people is well deserving of the honor. They have contributed to the sport in a unique way which caused them to stand out from their peers.
The difference between the UFC Hall of Fame and the hall of fame of other sports is subjectivity. In other sports, the writers elect the members of the hall of fame. In UFC, someone inside the organization puts them in. I believe that in order to legitimize the UFC Hall of Fame there needs to be some standards for induction. While, I do not foresee this happening, I do believe that there are some notable omissions to the UFC Hall of Fame. I believe that the number one thing that the UFC needs to do to legitimize their Hall of Fame is to induct several of the notable omissions. Here are 15 fighters I would argue for as worthy candidates for the UFC Hall of Fame:
1. Tito Ortiz - I believe that Tito Ortiz is the most deserving and most likely to be the next
fighters inducted into the UFC Hall of Fame. I was skeptical that Ortiz would ever be inducted due to his rocky relationship with UFC President, Dana White. It now seems that the relationship is somewhat mended. While Ortiz is a lightning rod for criticism he is a former UFC light heavyweight champion, who was immensely popular. Ortiz is just as deserving of this honor as many who are already there. With his retirement looming, look for him to be inducted in 2012.
2. B.J. Penn - B.J. Penn has retired from the sport, but most people do not think that he is really done. Regardless, Penn has the resume to be in the Hall of Fame. He is a former welterweight and lightweight champion. He has beaten many of the sports’ greats. Retired or not Penn is what other sports would call a first ballot hall of famer.
3. Mirko Cro Cop - Cro Cop’s run in the UFC was less than impressive, but his time in PRIDE made him a legend. I am assuming that UFC will eventually take into consideration the careers of PRIDE fighters. If they do, perhaps the first fighter to merit induction into the Hall of Fame would be Mirko Cro Cop, who at one time was one of the most feared fighters in the world.
4. Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira - Nogueira’s place in the UFC Hall of fame comes because Nogueira is the only fighter to hold championship belts in both UFC and PRIDE. Nogueira is widely regarded as one of the greatest heavyweight of all time. His record in the octagon is impressive, but also taken into consideration has to be his impact on the sport. Nogueira is a legend in Brazil and one of the most respected fighters in the game.
5. Vitor Belfort - Belfort has been around for a long time at a high level. He is a UFC heavyweight tournament champion, a former light heavyweight champion and a middleweight title contender. Belfort could stop fighting today and have a solid case for the hall of fame, but Belfort is trying to build on that legacy still.
6. Wanderlei Silva - Wanderlei Silva was the man in PRIDE. He is a legend. If the UFC hall of fame does not include “the Axe Murderer” it is incomplete. Wanderlei Silva had an incredible streak in Japan. Wanderlei may not have been dominant in the U.S., but he has had some solid wins over the likes of Keith Jardine, Michael Bisping and Cung Le. If I was a voter on a committee, i would vote for Wanderlei hands down.
7. Anderson Silva - The only reason Anderson Silva is not number one on this list is because he is not done fighting. I know some of the other guys are not either, but I just get the feeling his resume is still being built. Nevertheless, Anderson Silva will probably go down in history as the greatest mixed martial artist of all time. He has been dominant. He hasn’t lost in the UFC. he has smashed every UFC record imaginable. Simply put, he is the best. I would be all if favor of putting Anderson in the Hall of Fame right now. No one has a better resume for the UFC Hall of Fame…no one!
8. Brock Lesnar - This may be controversial. His record is not all that impressive. However, I put Lesnar here for two reasons. One, Lesnar was a former UFC heavyweight champion. While people hate Lesnar, there is no denying his skills. He jumped into the UFC and fought the best of the best and beat the likes of Frank Mir and Randy Couture. Second, Lesnar changed the sport. He is the biggest PPV draw in UFC history. He should be in not only for success in the cage, but also for what he did for the sport. Now that Lesnar is retired people will chew on his impact and career and I think an honest look merits a hall of fame nod.
9. Dan Henderson - I am not sure how the UFC will take into account a fighter’s career in other Zuffa purchased promotions like PRIDE and Strikeforce, but if that holds any weight Dan Henderson is a lock. He has fought the best of the best in 3 weight classes. He is a two division champion in PRIDE, a light heavyweight champion in Strikeforce and has fought for both the UFC middleweight and light heavyweight titles. Oh yea, he isn’t done. It appears as those Henderson will get another crack at a UFC title. If this is my ballot, I check “yes” for Henderson.
10. Pat Miletich - It gets a little bit sketchy the further we go back in history. However, if we go back in time, former welterweight champion Pat Miletich has to come on the radar. Miletich’s value is not just as a former UFC champion, but also as the famed trainer of Miletich Fighting Systems, which was the top camp for years. There is some friction between him and some inside the UFC, but that aside a solid case can be built to induct Miletich into the UFC hall of fame.
11. Frank Shamrock – If Shamrock makes the UFC Hall of Fame i will have a heart attack. His dispute with Dana White nearly assures this won’t happen, but I want to make the argument that based on performance as a fighter alone Shamrock is deserving. He defended the UFC light heavyweight title four times, including defeating Tito Ortiz. I think he has the credentials, but not the politics to get in.
12. Georges St. Pierre – His resume is good enough right now, but his legacy is still being writen. It is uncertain how he will rebound from a blown ACL, but St. Pierre is the most dominant welterweight champion in UFC history. He has beaten everybody. Also, he is crazy popular. St. Pierre is a lock for this honor…eventually.
13. Forrest Griffin - UFC president Dana White has said repeatedly that Forrest Griffin vs. Stephan Bonnar at the TUF 1 Finale may have been the most significant fight in UFC history. That alone may have earned Griffin the hall of fame nod. However, Griffin followed up his Ultimate Fighter victory with a run that lead to him becoming UFC light heavyweight champion. Griffin has the resume for sure and if I was a betting man, I would say this is likely a reality.
14. Rich Franklin – Franklin’s resume is not as impressive as some of the fighters above, but do not be mistaken, he has a solid resume. He is a former UFC champion, which instantly gets him in the conversation. However, Franklin has proven himself time and time again to be an elite fighter. He has done very well in two weight classes and should be considered for the hall of fame. Not only is Franklin a great fighter, but he has consistently been a great ambassador for the sport.
15. Quinton “Rampage” Jackson – Rampage etched out his legacy in both PRIDE and UFC. He is one of a few fighters to have success in both organizations. He is a former UFC light heavyweight champion who is still a top ranked fighter. I would venture that rampage will find his way to the UFC Hall of Fame by the time his career is finished.
I think there are others who are well on their way to being in the UFC hall of fame like Jon Jones and Jose Aldo. I also think you could make arguments for fighters like Urijah Faber, and Frank Mir. Heck, I think argument could be made for Forrest Griffin, Kenny Florian, Takanori Gomi, Lyoto Machida, Shogun Rua, Jens Pulver, Rashad Evans, and Michael Bisping and perhaps even Chael Sonnen. Perhaps UFC could consider some “blasts from the past” like Bas Rutten or Evan Tanner. Perhaps they could consider some other memorable PRIDE fighters such as Kazushi Sakuraba or Fedor Emelianenko. I wouldn’t fuss over Josh Koscheck or Jon Fitch being considered. Then again, it is the “hall of fame” and not the “hall of good”. It seems inevitable that guys like Frankie Edgar and Dominick Cruz will build their cases as well. All of this does not even take into account non-fighters who are well-deserving. People like Bruce Buffer, Mike Goldberg and Joe Rogan have become a huge part of the UFC. A UFC hall of fame also would not be complete without people like Dana White himself and Lorenzo and Frank Fertitta.